Woops, my mistake, there would be no question if the V5 was that powerfull!

I have read some reviews on the V5 and as you mentioned the engine is a bit rough.

I also considered the opportunity of tuning and the fact that the GTI has more benefits.

I checked prices on insurance and they are virtually the same, on the downside i would imagine that the V5 would drink like a fish and the tax would be pretty extortionate.

I suppose the GTI looks like the best option, i have a while before i make my choice so i will keep my opinion open until the time comes.

What insurance group is your V6 if you dont mind me asking? and also tax, fuel consumption etc...? Has it served you well?

Cheers for the info.