Re: 89 jetta erratic idle
Not sure which engine your Jetta has but I used to have a Jetta 16v which I loved and still miss to this day.
Here's some suggestions:
Change your mechanic - it sounds like he doesn't know how to fix it.
Is your throttle cable moving smoothly? sounds like something's sticking. If you have a carb something could be sticking in there?
Not sure about your battery prob really having much of an effect on the idle problem, but I might be wrong.
Hope I've helped.
Re: 89 jetta erratic idle
Possibly a knackered Idle Control Valve. Is it an injection model?
Just realised another very old thread.