ricardoh
15-09-2008, 10:30 PM
Hello
My first post and I'm not particularly mechanically minded so please forgive any ignorance I show! My Golf 2.0TDI MkV 04 plate broke an engine mount when it was just inside the 3 year warranty. The left side of the engine dropped and the car ground to a very noisy halt (I was only going slowly at teh time; thank god).
The bolt was replaced by VW and I think it was from that point on, that when turning left over bumpy road surfaces, I started to hear knocking from the front right.
My local VW dealer diagnosed a bad shock absorber and as it was under warranty they decided to do a BIG job replacing shocks both sides, springs both sides and 'top mounts?' both sides.
Despite all the replaced parts, I still hear knocks but I emphasise only when turning left over bumpy road surfaces. It's been back into VW several times but it's not cured and I'm so frustrated!!!
I even took it to another non VW workshop who replaced a vertical strut (droplinks?) on both sides but the knock still perists.
The VW dealer has since changed a triangular shape hunk of metal on the right side and a bottom mount of some kind with a great ring of rubber in it but still no good.
I never hear the noise when turning right, no matter how hard I turn or bumpy the corner. Any suggestions would be much appreciated. P.S. It's more likely to knock if there is no braking taking place i.e. the front right corner of the car is 'floppy', not under compression.
Here's hoping for a suggestion that will lead to a cure and thanks in advance to anyone replying. Richard
My first post and I'm not particularly mechanically minded so please forgive any ignorance I show! My Golf 2.0TDI MkV 04 plate broke an engine mount when it was just inside the 3 year warranty. The left side of the engine dropped and the car ground to a very noisy halt (I was only going slowly at teh time; thank god).
The bolt was replaced by VW and I think it was from that point on, that when turning left over bumpy road surfaces, I started to hear knocking from the front right.
My local VW dealer diagnosed a bad shock absorber and as it was under warranty they decided to do a BIG job replacing shocks both sides, springs both sides and 'top mounts?' both sides.
Despite all the replaced parts, I still hear knocks but I emphasise only when turning left over bumpy road surfaces. It's been back into VW several times but it's not cured and I'm so frustrated!!!
I even took it to another non VW workshop who replaced a vertical strut (droplinks?) on both sides but the knock still perists.
The VW dealer has since changed a triangular shape hunk of metal on the right side and a bottom mount of some kind with a great ring of rubber in it but still no good.
I never hear the noise when turning right, no matter how hard I turn or bumpy the corner. Any suggestions would be much appreciated. P.S. It's more likely to knock if there is no braking taking place i.e. the front right corner of the car is 'floppy', not under compression.
Here's hoping for a suggestion that will lead to a cure and thanks in advance to anyone replying. Richard